Contact Us for a Free Consultation 304-755-1101

Blog

PROTECTING THE MEANING AND VALUE OF AMERICAN CITIZENSHIP - Key Highlights of the Executive Order

Posted by Paul Saluja | Jan 21, 2025

1. Purpose and Constitutional Context

The order revisits the Fourteenth Amendment, underscoring its intent to provide citizenship to individuals born or naturalized in the U.S., subject to its jurisdiction. However, it argues that this provision excludes individuals born to:

  • Mothers unlawfully present in the U.S. if the father is not a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident.
  • Mothers lawfully present on a temporary basis (e.g., tourists, students, workers) if the father is not a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident.

This interpretation aligns with the premise that "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" imposes limits on automatic citizenship, emphasizing the legal status of parents at the time of birth.


2. Policy Shift

Effective 30 days from the order's issuance, U.S. government agencies are prohibited from recognizing citizenship for individuals born under the outlined exclusions. The directive does not affect individuals born to lawful permanent residents or those already recognized as U.S. citizens.


3. Implementation and Enforcement

Key federal agencies, including the Department of State, Department of Homeland Security, and Department of Justice, are tasked with issuing guidance and ensuring compliance. Public-facing policies are expected to reflect this change within 30 days, setting the stage for immediate enforcement.


Implications of the Executive Order

For Immigrants and Families

This order introduces significant complexities for individuals seeking recognition of U.S. citizenship for their children. Families with mixed immigration statuses may face additional challenges in securing documentation or asserting their rights under U.S. law.

For Broader Immigration Policy

This directive raises questions about the evolving interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment and its alignment with legislative authority under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA). It also sets the stage for potential legal challenges at both state and federal levels.


Challenges and Controversy

Constitutional Concerns

The order's reinterpretation of "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is likely to face scrutiny in courts. Critics argue that the Fourteenth Amendment has historically provided broad protections for individuals born on U.S. soil, regardless of parental immigration status.

Practical Enforcement

Implementation may prove complex, as federal agencies must overhaul existing policies and coordinate across departments to enforce these changes.

Impact on Vulnerable Populations

Children born in the U.S. under temporary or undocumented circumstances may face a precarious legal status, potentially limiting their access to education, healthcare, and other fundamental rights.


Saluja Law's Perspective

At Saluja Law, we believe that any policy impacting fundamental rights like citizenship must be carefully examined for its constitutional validity and practical consequences. This executive order challenges established precedents and introduces uncertainty for families, immigrants, and legal practitioners alike.

If you or your loved ones are affected by this policy, or if you have concerns about how this order impacts your rights, we're here to help. Our team is committed to navigating these complex legal waters to ensure that justice and fairness prevail.

Contact Saluja Law today for expert legal guidance on immigration and citizenship matters.

About the Author

Paul Saluja

Paul Saluja is a distinguished legal professional with over two decades of experience serving clients across a spectrum of legal domains. Graduating from West Virginia State University in 1988 with a bachelor's degree in chemistry, he continued his academic journey at Ohio Northern University, gr...

Contact Us Today

Specializing in Immigration and Business Law on an international scale, Saluja Law Offices PLLC operates out of West Virginia and handles Family law cases within the local community.

We offer a Free Consultation and we'll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.

Menu